BreakThru Realty

33189 Homes for Sale: Cutler Bay, FL

Buying or selling in 33189? Start with what homes here actually sell for and a plan built around your move.

104 homes and condos for sale in ZIP code 33189, Cutler Bay, FL, with median prices for houses and condos, recent sales and neighborhoods, updated daily from the MLS.

33189 Market at a Glance

Updated October 29, 2026 from BeachesMLS.

Newest 33189 Homes for Sale

See every 33189 home for sale with map and filters.

Single-family homesCondos & townhomes
Active listings7430
Median list price$682,500$254,500
Median list price per sq ft$382/sq ft$278/sq ft
Average days on market79 days116 days
Sold in the last 90 days3613
Median sold price (90 days)$600,000$253,500
Sale price as % of list price99.1%96.3%
Months of inventory6.2 months6.9 months
Median sold price vs. a year ago+1%-38.5%

Source: BeachesMLS. Active listings as of October 29, 2026; sold figures cover closings in the last 90 days, compared with the same 90 days one year earlier. Not an appraisal. How these figures are calculated.

Homes for Sale in 33189

104 homes and condos are for sale in ZIP code 33189 today, 6 of them new this week. Most 33189 addresses file under Cutler Bay, so a ZIP search can cross a city line; the listings below show each home's own city. Single-family homes in the ZIP are asking a median $682,500 and condos and townhomes $254,500.

What Homes Sell For in 33189

Over the last 90 days single-family homes in 33189 sold at a median $600,000 and condos and townhomes at $253,500. Single-family homes carry 6.2 months of inventory and condos 6.9; under four months favours sellers, over six favours buyers. The recent sales below show individual closing prices; a valuation for a specific home starts from the closings closest to it.

Neighborhoods in 33189

The listings in 33189 today include homes in Saga Bay, Cutler Ridge, South Coral Homes, Lakes by the Bay, Cutler Creek, Cantamar and more. Each neighborhood page carries its own listings, recent sales and a local guide.

Neighborhood Pages in 33189

Homes for Sale in 33189

46 newest listings; see every 33189 home with map and filters.

Recently Sold in 33189

33189 Real Estate: Frequently Asked Questions

What is the median home price in 33189?
Over the last 90 days the median sold price in ZIP code 33189 was $600,000 for single-family homes and $253,500 for condos and townhomes, from MLS closings. These figures refresh daily on this page.
What city is ZIP code 33189 in?
Most addresses in 33189 are in Cutler Bay. ZIP codes follow postal routes rather than city limits, so confirm the municipality on the property record for taxes, schools and building rules.
How many homes are for sale in 33189?
104 homes and condos are listed for sale in 33189 today, and 13 sold in the last 30 days, from the MLS. The listings on this page update throughout the day.
What is my home in 33189 worth?
Request a free valuation and a BreakThru broker builds it from the recent closed sales closest to your home in 33189, adjusted for size, condition, water and upgrades. The recent sales on this page are a good first look at what nearby homes have sold for.

33189 Homes by Price Range

Explore