BreakThru Realty

Teardown or Renovate? How to Decide Before You Buy

Seven questions that settle it

BreakThru Realty helps buyers find a home in the right location that needs work, then coordinates the architects, designers and licensed contractors who turn it into the home they wanted. For an older house on a good lot, the first decision is the largest: keep the structure and renovate, or remove it and build new. This guide sets out the questions that decide it, in the order worth asking them.

BreakThru Realty · Founder and Broker of Record: Tyson E. Sam, Florida License 3565210

Request a Potential Check

1. Is the Structure Worth Keeping?

Start with the bones. A sound foundation, solid block walls and a roof structure in good order are worth a great deal, and a renovation that keeps them saves real cost and time. Settlement cracks, corroded reinforcing steel, long-term water intrusion or termite damage change the answer. A structural engineer’s opinion, obtained during the inspection period, is inexpensive next to the decision it informs.

2. How Much of the House Would the Plan Keep?

List what your plan replaces. If it keeps the walls and roof and changes the inside, it is a renovation. If it moves most walls, replaces the roof, every system, every window and adds a floor, you may be paying renovation prices to keep little more than a slab, while accepting the old house’s ceiling heights and floor level. The closer the plan comes to replacing everything, the stronger the case for starting again.

3. What Does the Flood Zone Say?

In a Special Flood Hazard Area this question can decide the matter alone. A renovation that reaches half the market value of the structure must bring the whole building up to current flood requirements, which for a low-lying older house can mean elevating it. A new home is simply built at the required elevation. If your renovation would cross that line, compare it with new construction on equal terms.

4. What Would the Zoning Let You Build?

An older house sometimes sits closer to a property line, or covers more of the lot, than today’s zoning would allow a new one to. Removing it can mean giving that up. In other cases the zoning allows far more house than is there now, and the lot is underused. Historic designation can take demolition off the table entirely. An architect’s reading of the zoning against the survey tells you which situation you are in.

5. What Do the Two Totals Look Like?

Compare complete totals, not construction prices. For each route, add the purchase, the construction cost from written bids, design, engineering and permit costs, demolition where it applies, a contingency, and the cost of living elsewhere for the duration. Renovations carry more risk of hidden conditions; new construction carries a longer schedule. A lender will also treat them differently, so the financing belongs in the comparison.

6. How Long Can You Wait?

A renovation is usually faster than a new build, because design is simpler and the shell already exists. A new home adds demolition, more extensive design and engineering, and a longer permit review and construction period. If you need to be in the home by a certain date, or are paying for other housing in the meantime, time is a cost and may decide a close call.

7. What Will the Finished Home Be Worth There?

Finally, look at the street. What finished, renovated homes and new homes sell for in that neighborhood tells you how much either project can sensibly cost. Spending more than the neighborhood supports can still be right for a home you will live in for decades, but it should be a choice made knowingly. Recent sales nearby, which your agent can pull from the MLS, are the evidence.

Request a Potential Check

A few questions about where and how you want to live. An agent reads every answer and follows up personally. Nothing here asks about credit, income or debts.

Prefer to talk? (786) 914-1017 · sales@breakthrurealty.com

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if a house is a teardown?
A house is a teardown candidate when the land carries most of its value and the structure is at the end of its useful life, or when the home you want cannot be made from it within the flood and zoning rules. A structural engineer, an architect and a licensed contractor can answer that for a specific property.
Is it always cheaper to renovate than to build new?
No. A light or moderate renovation usually costs less than a new home. A renovation that replaces nearly everything, or that triggers flood elevation requirements, can approach or pass the cost of building new, without the benefits of a new structure.
Can I decide after I buy?
You can, but the cheapest time to find out is before closing. During the inspection period you can have the structure, flood zone and zoning checked, and still renegotiate or cancel if neither route works.
Who should I ask?
A structural engineer for the condition of the building, an architect for what the zoning allows, a licensed general contractor for the cost of each route, and the city’s building department for flood and permit questions. The Potential Check brings those opinions together during your inspection period.

Sources

Rules are summarized for buyers and change. The city or county building department, the floodplain administrator and the association decide for a specific property.

BreakThru Realty is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Design and construction are performed by licensed, insured professionals you choose, under your own agreements with them.

More From BreakThru Dream Home Project

Related on BreakThru Realty