Fisher Island Recently Leased Homes & Condos
Closed BeachesMLS leases in Fisher Island, Florida from the last six months, newest first: the rent each home actually leased at, not the rent it was asking.
The homes that leased recently on Fisher Island are the figures a tenant or an owner should price from, because asking rents on the island are set by a small number of owners and vary with the furnishings as much as the plan. Each entry shows the rent a Seaside, Bayside, Bayview, Oceanside or Palazzo residence actually closed at, how it compared with the asking rent and how long it took to lease, which together say more about the Fisher Island season than any listing still on the market. An owner setting a winter or annual rent and a tenant deciding what to offer both start from these closings rather than from the asking rents.
What would my Fisher Island home rent for? · Leasing and property management
Recent Fisher Island Leases
5 closed leases, newest first.
The 5 leases on this page run from $17,000 a month to $30,000 a month, with a median of $25,000 a month, about $9 per square foot a month, and they leased in a median of 140 days.
Leased $17,000/mo
Leased Sep 15, 2026 · 5245 Fisher Island Drive 5245, Miami Beach FL 33109
2 bd · 3 ba · 1,950 sq ft · $8.72/sq ft a month · 20 days on market · 94.4% of asking rentLeased $25,000/mo
Leased Sep 15, 2026 · 2124 Fisher Island Drive 2124, Miami Beach FL 33109
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,744 sq ft · $9.11/sq ft a month · 0 days on market · 125% of asking rentLeased $30,000/mo
Leased Jul 31, 2026 · 19222 Fisher Island Drive 19222, Miami Beach FL 33109
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,049 sq ft · $14.64/sq ft a month · 298 days on market · 85.7% of asking rentLeased $30,000/mo
Leased Jun 10, 2026 · 7471 Fisher Island Drive 7471, Miami Beach FL 33109
5 bd · 6 ba · 4,932 sq ft · $6.08/sq ft a month · 140 days on market · 60% of asking rentLeased $24,000/mo
Leased Jun 1, 2026 · 4924 Fisher Island Drive 4924, Miami Beach FL 33109
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,740 sq ft · $8.76/sq ft a month · 154 days on market · 85.7% of asking rent
How to Read These Leases
Each card shows the rent the lease closed at, the date it closed, the rent per square foot where the home reports its size, the days it sat on the market and what share of the asking rent it achieved. A figure over 100% means the home leased above its asking rent; under 100% means the owner took less than they asked. A lease quoted as a season or a one-time total is labelled that way rather than shown as a monthly rent, because the two are not comparable.
Own a Home in Fisher Island?
These closings are what a Fisher Island rental valuation is built on. We price your home against the leases closest to it in size, condition and location, not against a citywide average. Request a free rental analysis.
Search Fisher Island Rentals
By Home Type
- Fisher Island Apartments for Rent
- Fisher Island Condos for Rent
- Fisher Island 1 Bedroom Apartments & Condos for Rent
- Fisher Island 2 Bedroom Apartments & Homes for Rent
- Fisher Island 4+ Bedroom Homes for Rent
- Fisher Island 3+ Bedroom Homes for Rent
On the Water
- Fisher Island Waterfront Rentals
- Fisher Island Rentals with a Dock & Ocean Access
- Fisher Island Rentals with No Fixed Bridges
- Fisher Island Intracoastal Homes & Condos for Rent
Lifestyle & Lease
Recently Leased
Explore
- Fisher Island rentals: market data and guide
- Fisher Island property management & leasing
- Fisher Island real estate: homes for sale and market data
- Work with a BreakThru rental agent
- A renter's guide to South Florida
- How Fisher Island rents compare with every other South Florida city
- Florida homes for rent by city and county
- Miami-Dade County real estate