How much is rent in Fisher Island?

The median asking rent in Fisher Island is $29,000 a month across 36 active rentals in BeachesMLS. These figures update daily on this page.

Do I pay a fee to rent a home in Fisher Island through BreakThru Realty?

In most South Florida rentals the landlord pays the agent commission, so working with a BreakThru rental agent costs a renter nothing. If a specific listing works differently, we tell you before you tour it.

What do I need to apply for a rental in Fisher Island?

Most landlords ask for a government-issued photo ID, recent pay stubs or an offer letter showing income of roughly three times the monthly rent, recent bank statements, a credit report and rental references. Having these ready before you tour lets you apply the same day.

How long does rental approval take in Fisher Island?

Landlord approval usually takes one to three business days. If the home is in a condo or HOA community, which is common in Fisher Island, the association runs its own application and approval, and that can take two to four weeks in many buildings. We start the association paperwork the moment you are accepted.

Can I rent a pet-friendly home in Fisher Island?

Yes. The pet-friendly page lists every current Fisher Island rental whose listing says pets are allowed. Most still set limits, such as breed or size restrictions, a maximum number of pets and a pet fee or deposit, and condo associations often add rules of their own, so we confirm the policy for your pet before you apply.

Fisher Island Rentals: Homes & Apartments for Rent

Every house, condo and apartment for rent in Fisher Island, Florida, straight from BeachesMLS and updated throughout the day, with live rent figures and local agents who know which buildings and streets are worth your application.

Tell us what you want and we will find it · Lease your Fisher Island home · What would my Fisher Island home rent for?

Fisher Island Rental Market at a Glance

Updated October 20, 2026 from BeachesMLS.

36homes for rent
$29,000/momedian asking rent
1new rentals this week
1leased in the last 30 days

	Houses & townhomes	Condos & apartments
Active rentals	0	36
Median asking rent	—	$29,000/mo
Median rent per sq ft	—	$14.26/sq ft
Average days on market	—	580 days
Leased in the last 90 days	0	4
Median leased rent (90 days)	—	$27,500/mo
Median leased rent vs. a year ago	—	+1.9%

Source: BeachesMLS. Asking rents are active rentals as of October 20, 2026; leased rents cover leases signed in the last 90 days, compared with the same 90 days one year earlier. Not an appraisal.

Newest Fisher Island Rentals

The 24 newest are below; see every match with map and filters.

The 24 listings on this page run from $15,750 a month to $85,000 a month, with a median of $29,500 a month, and they have been listed a median of 209 days.

Fisher Island Rent by Bedroom Count

Asking rents in Fisher Island by size right now: studios and one-bedrooms $13,950, 2-bedrooms $19,950, 3-bedrooms $30,000, 4-bedrooms $48,000 a month, medians of the homes listed today.

Size	Listed now	Median asking rent	Days on market	Leased, last 90 days	Median achieved rent
Studio & 1 bedroom	2	$13,950/mo	797	0	—
2 bedrooms	10	$19,950/mo	578	1	$17,000/mo
3 bedrooms	19	$30,000/mo	664	2	$27,500/mo
4+ bedrooms	5	$48,000/mo	179	1	$72,000/mo

Source: BeachesMLS, monthly rents only; updated daily.

Renting in Fisher Island

Fisher Island rentals are furnished condominium residences in the villages, leased by their owners for a season or a year: ocean-direct units in Seaside Village and Oceanside, bay and skyline views in Bayside Village and Bayview, the occasional Marina Village studio, and full-service residences in Palazzo del Sol and Palazzo della Luna. Tenants are families relocating to Miami, executives, owners living on the island while a renovation or a new building is finished, and winter residents who want the beach club and the privacy of the ferry. Every tenant is approved by the association and registered with the island's security, and most leases run for the season or twelve months rather than by the week.

Houses, Condos and Apartments

Rentals in Fisher Island range from studio apartments to furnished estate homes. The market table on this page splits the median rent between houses and townhomes on one side and condos and apartments on the other, because the two markets price very differently, and the pages below narrow the search by home type, monthly rent, furnishing, pets and lease length.

How Renting With BreakThru Works

Tell us your budget, move-in date and must-haves, and a licensed rental agent builds a shortlist, schedules tours and helps you apply with a complete file. In most South Florida rentals the landlord pays the agent commission, so our help costs a renter nothing.

Own a Home in Fisher Island?

A Fisher Island landlord leases a furnished residence at the top of the Miami market, and the decisions are about terms rather than demand: the season or the year, what the rent includes from utilities and housekeeping to the club privileges a tenant may use, the inventory of furnishings, and the association's minimum lease term, number of leases a year and tenant approval, which differ from village to village. Club access for tenants is set by the Fisher Island Club and confirmed before advertising. We check those rules first, then price your home from live Fisher Island rents and the leases that actually closed.

Renting in Fisher Island: What to Know Before You Apply

Where renters live

Renters on Fisher Island live in the villages, because the island has almost no houses to let. Seaside Village and the Seaside Villas sit on the beach beside the club, with ground-floor homes that open to the gardens and upper floors that look over the Atlantic. Bayside Village wraps the inner marina, Bayview faces Biscayne Bay and the Miami skyline, and Marina Village has the smallest units above the slips. The Palazzo buildings on Government Cut offer full-service residences with private elevators. Everything on Fisher Island is reached by the car ferry from the MacArthur Causeway or by boat, and the beach club, golf course, restaurants and day school are on the island itself.

Annual or seasonal

Fisher Island rents in two rhythms. Winter tenants take furnished residences for the season, often returning to the same village each year, and the ocean-direct homes in Seaside and Oceanside are spoken for first. Annual tenants are families relocating to Miami, executives and owners waiting on a renovation or a new building, and they take the larger homes in Bayside Village, Bayview and the Palazzo buildings for a year at a time. Nearly every rental on Fisher Island comes furnished whatever the term. A winter stay should be arranged by early autumn; an annual lease is easiest to find in late spring, when the season ends and owners decide between another winter tenant and a year-round one.

What to have ready

A Fisher Island application is reviewed by the owner, the village association and the island's security, so arrive with a complete file: photo identification for every adult, proof of income or assets, bank and landlord references, consent to credit and background checks, and details of pets, vehicles, boats and household staff. For a furnished residence the owner will also want to know who will stay and for how long. Many Fisher Island owners live abroad or up north, and the association meets on its own schedule, so a full packet sent before the showing shortens the wait and lets the ferry and gate registration begin as soon as the owner says yes.

Association approval

Every rental on Fisher Island passes through an association, and the village's approval is what sets the move-in date. Each association runs its own application, charges a fee, sets a minimum lease term and a limit on leases a year, and may interview the tenant before approving. The island's community association then registers the tenant, their guests and their vehicles with security and the ferry. Use of the beach club, golf course, tennis and restaurants by a tenant is decided by the Fisher Island Club under its own rules rather than by the owner, so ask what privileges come with the lease before you commit, and allow several weeks for the approvals to run.

Deposits and move-in costs

Deposits on a Fisher Island rental reflect a furnished home at the top of the Miami market. Expect first and last month's rent and a security deposit sized to the furnishings and finishes, with the inventory attached to the lease and photographed on arrival, plus the association's application fee and, in some villages, a separate building deposit. A seasonal tenant usually pays the whole term in advance. The lease should state who pays utilities, housekeeping, parking and any club charges, and how ferry access for guests and deliveries works. Florida law governs how a Fisher Island security deposit is held and returned, and the condition report at move-in is what protects it.

Search Fisher Island Rentals

By Home Type

On the Water

Lifestyle & Lease

Recently Leased

Fisher Island Recently Leased Homes & Condos

Fisher Island Property Management & Leasing Services

Fisher Island Rentals FAQ

How much is rent in Fisher Island?: The median asking rent in Fisher Island is $29,000 a month across 36 active rentals in BeachesMLS. These figures update daily on this page.
Do I pay a fee to rent a home in Fisher Island through BreakThru Realty?: In most South Florida rentals the landlord pays the agent commission, so working with a BreakThru rental agent costs a renter nothing. If a specific listing works differently, we tell you before you tour it.
What do I need to apply for a rental in Fisher Island?: Most landlords ask for a government-issued photo ID, recent pay stubs or an offer letter showing income of roughly three times the monthly rent, recent bank statements, a credit report and rental references. Having these ready before you tour lets you apply the same day.
How long does rental approval take in Fisher Island?: Landlord approval usually takes one to three business days. If the home is in a condo or HOA community, which is common in Fisher Island, the association runs its own application and approval, and that can take two to four weeks in many buildings. We start the association paperwork the moment you are accepted.
Can I rent a pet-friendly home in Fisher Island?: Yes. The pet-friendly page lists every current Fisher Island rental whose listing says pets are allowed. Most still set limits, such as breed or size restrictions, a maximum number of pets and a pet fee or deposit, and condo associations often add rules of their own, so we confirm the policy for your pet before you apply.