Bay Harbor Islands Apartments for Rent

Live BeachesMLS rentals matching this search in Bay Harbor Islands, Florida, updated throughout the day.

Apartments for rent in Bay Harbor Islands are the units in the East Island's mid-century garden buildings, two and three stories on the numbered streets, where a landlord or a small management company rents directly without an association to approve the tenant. They are the simplest way onto the island: a renovated one- or two-bedroom with a parking space, a walk from Kane Concourse and the public school and a bridge from the beach. A purpose-built rental building adds newer apartments with a leasing office and amenities. Ask about laundry, parking and the age of the windows, which vary from one Bay Harbor Islands building to the next.

16 rentals, newest first.

The 16 listings on this page run from $1,200 a month to $4,200 a month, with a median of $2,350 a month, and they have been listed a median of 133 days.

Need Help Finding the Right Rental?

A licensed BreakThru rental agent can build your shortlist, schedule tours and help you apply, and in most South Florida rentals the landlord pays our fee. Start your rental search.

Search Bay Harbor Islands Rentals

By Home Type

On the Water

Lifestyle & Lease

Recently Leased

Bay Harbor Islands Property Management & Leasing Services

Explore