BreakThru Realty

4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City, FL 34990

Sold $1,200,000 · Jul 15, 2026

Last asking price $1,250,000 · 96% of asking · 27 days on market

Similar Homes for Sale Nearby

  • 3 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,082 sq ft
  • Single Family Residence
  • Built 1992
  • Lot 217,800 sq ft
  • Martin County
  • MLS# M20055620
  • Palm City Farms
Front of home with walk way to Gazebo. at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityPhoto 2 at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityEntry Porch at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityFront door at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityFoyer at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityPhoto 6 at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityGreat room with Fireplace at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm CityGreat room view at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

About this home

Escape to your own private retreat on five fenced acres with private gated entry. This unique chalet-style 3BR/2BA home features a two story fieldstone fireplace, cedar interior, hardwood floors, and an open-concept design with incredible pond and gazebo views. Multiple-level deck with walkway to charming gazebo create the perfect setting to relax and enjoy the lush Old Florida vegetation surrounding the property. Equestrian enthusiasts will appreciate the three-stall barn with feed and tack room. Additional features include a detached metal building ideal for a garage or man cave, covered RV/trailer parking, workshop/potting shed as well as additional storage shed. A rare blend of rustic charm, privacy, and functionality that feels like a getaway every time you come home yet conveniently located close to shopping, schools, restaurants and only 13 miles to Stuart Beach. You really can have it all at the "Ponderosa".

Features

  • Built-in Features
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Vaulted Ceiling(s)
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Bedroom Layout - Split
  • Upstairs Living Area
  • Balcony
  • Lake Access
  • Pond

Schools

  • Elementary: Crystal Lake (Martin)
  • Middle: Dr. David L. Anderson
  • High: South Fork

Presented by

BreakThru Realty · (786) 914-1017

Courtesy of

Berkshire Hathaway Florida Rea · terrikasnic@bhhsfloridarealty.com · Listing agent: Joan Rogers

BeachesMLS logo All listings featuring the BMLS logo are provided by BeachesMLS, Inc. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by BeachesMLS. Listings held by brokerage firms other than BreakThru Realty carry the name of the listing broker.

Thinking of Selling Nearby?

4558 SW Cherokee Street sold on Jul 15, 2026. Your buyer may already be looking. BreakThru Realty works with hundreds of prequalified buyers searching for properties. A broker compares your home in Palm City Farms with this sale and the closings nearest it, checks it against the buyers on file and calls you with your selling options. Find Out If We Have Your Buyer, or see homes for sale in Palm City. Call or text BreakThru Realty at (786) 914-1017 or email sales@breakthrurealty.com.

Questions About 4558 SW Cherokee Street

What did 4558 SW Cherokee Street sell for?
4558 SW Cherokee Street sold for $1,200,000 on Jul 15, 2026, about 96% of its last asking price of $1,250,000 and about $576 per square foot. Recent sales like this one are what buyers and sellers nearby price against.
What are the property taxes on 4558 SW Cherokee Street?
The listing reported annual property taxes of $4,168 for 2025. Taxes are reassessed at the sale price after a purchase, so the new owner's bill will differ from that figure.
When was 4558 SW Cherokee Street built?
4558 SW Cherokee Street was built in 1992 and the listing describes its condition as resale. Age matters for insurance and financing in Florida: ask about the roof, the electrical panel and, for a condo built before the current code, the building's structural reserve study.
How long was 4558 SW Cherokee Street on the market?
4558 SW Cherokee Street was on the market for 27 days before it sold.
Is 4558 SW Cherokee Street waterfront?
Yes. The listing described the water as lake access pond.
Which schools serve 4558 SW Cherokee Street?
The MLS lists Crystal Lake (Martin) (elementary), Dr. David L. Anderson (middle), South Fork (high). School assignments are set by the district and can change; verify them with the school board before you rely on them.
Is 4558 SW Cherokee Street still for sale?
No. 4558 SW Cherokee Street sold on Jul 15, 2026. BreakThru Realty can show you similar homes for sale nearby, or tell you what a home like yours would sell for today; call or text and a licensed agent will follow up.

Explore

Recently Sold Nearby

Explore Nearby

Nearby Cities

More Palm City Neighborhoods

Nearby ZIP Codes

A comparable home, 5023 SW Martin Commons Way, Palm City, FL 34990, sold for $950,000 in October 2026. Other Palm City neighborhoods include Highlands Reserve and Cobblestone. Nearby ZIP codes include 34994 and 34996. This property also neighbors Stuart, Sewall's Point, and Ocean Breeze. Compare it with the Palm City housing market report.