How much is 4558 SW Cherokee Street?

4558 SW Cherokee Street is listed at $1,250,000, which is about $600 per square foot. The listing page shows comparable active listings and recent closed sales nearby so you can judge the asking price against what buyers have actually paid.

What are the property taxes on 4558 SW Cherokee Street?

The listing reports annual property taxes of $4,168 for 2025. Taxes are reassessed at the sale price after a purchase, so a new owner's bill can differ from the current owner's; use the mortgage calculator on this page for an estimate.

When was 4558 SW Cherokee Street built?

4558 SW Cherokee Street was built in 1992 and the listing describes its condition as resale. Age matters for insurance and financing in Florida: ask about the roof, the electrical panel and, for a condo built before the current code, the building's structural reserve study.

How long has 4558 SW Cherokee Street been on the market?

4558 SW Cherokee Street has been listed for 27 days. Days on market and price changes are the first signals of how much room there is to negotiate.

Is 4558 SW Cherokee Street waterfront?

Yes. The listing describes the water as lake access pond. For a home with dockage, confirm the water depth at low tide, the seawall condition and whether the route to the inlet passes under any fixed bridges before you offer.

Which schools serve 4558 SW Cherokee Street?

The MLS lists Crystal Lake (Martin) (elementary), Dr. David L. Anderson (middle), South Fork (high). School assignments are set by the district and can change; verify them with the school board before you rely on them.

How do I see 4558 SW Cherokee Street?

Request a showing from this page or call BreakThru Realty and a licensed agent will arrange a private tour, in person or by video, and answer anything the listing leaves out.

4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City, FL 34990

$1,250,000 · Closed

3 beds
2 baths
2,082 sq ft
Single Family Residence
Built 1992
Lot 217,800 sq ft
MLS# M20055620
Palm City Farms

Front of home with walk way to Gazebo. at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Photo 2 at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Entry Porch at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Front door at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Foyer at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Photo 6 at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Great room with Fireplace at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

Great room view at 4558 SW Cherokee Street, Palm City

About this home

Escape to your own private retreat on five fenced acres with private gated entry. This unique chalet-style 3BR/2BA home features a two story fieldstone fireplace, cedar interior, hardwood floors, and an open-concept design with incredible pond and gazebo views. Multiple-level deck with walkway to charming gazebo create the perfect setting to relax and enjoy the lush Old Florida vegetation surrounding the property. Equestrian enthusiasts will appreciate the three-stall barn with feed and tack room. Additional features include a detached metal building ideal for a garage or man cave, covered RV/trailer parking, workshop/potting shed as well as additional storage shed. A rare blend of rustic charm, privacy, and functionality that feels like a getaway every time you come home yet conveniently located close to shopping, schools, restaurants and only 13 miles to Stuart Beach. You really can have it all at the "Ponderosa".

Features

Built-in Features
Cathedral Ceiling(s)
Entrance Foyer
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Walk-In Closet(s)
Bedroom Layout - Split
Upstairs Living Area
Balcony
Lake Access
Pond

Schools

Elementary: Crystal Lake (Martin)
Middle: Dr. David L. Anderson
High: South Fork

Presented by

BreakThru Realty · (786) 914-1017

Courtesy of

Berkshire Hathaway Florida Realty · Listing agent: Joan Rogers

Schedule a showing

Call or text BreakThru Realty at (786) 914-1017 or email sales@breakthrurealty.com to see 4558 SW Cherokee Street.

Questions About 4558 SW Cherokee Street

How much is 4558 SW Cherokee Street?: 4558 SW Cherokee Street is listed at $1,250,000, which is about $600 per square foot. The listing page shows comparable active listings and recent closed sales nearby so you can judge the asking price against what buyers have actually paid.
What are the property taxes on 4558 SW Cherokee Street?: The listing reports annual property taxes of $4,168 for 2025. Taxes are reassessed at the sale price after a purchase, so a new owner's bill can differ from the current owner's; use the mortgage calculator on this page for an estimate.
When was 4558 SW Cherokee Street built?: 4558 SW Cherokee Street was built in 1992 and the listing describes its condition as resale. Age matters for insurance and financing in Florida: ask about the roof, the electrical panel and, for a condo built before the current code, the building's structural reserve study.
How long has 4558 SW Cherokee Street been on the market?: 4558 SW Cherokee Street has been listed for 27 days. Days on market and price changes are the first signals of how much room there is to negotiate.
Is 4558 SW Cherokee Street waterfront?: Yes. The listing describes the water as lake access pond. For a home with dockage, confirm the water depth at low tide, the seawall condition and whether the route to the inlet passes under any fixed bridges before you offer.
Which schools serve 4558 SW Cherokee Street?: The MLS lists Crystal Lake (Martin) (elementary), Dr. David L. Anderson (middle), South Fork (high). School assignments are set by the district and can change; verify them with the school board before you rely on them.
How do I see 4558 SW Cherokee Street?: Request a showing from this page or call BreakThru Realty and a licensed agent will arrange a private tour, in person or by video, and answer anything the listing leaves out.

Explore

Similar Homes Nearby

5080 SW 69th Street, Palm City, FL 34990 · $1,325,000 · 4 bd · 3 ba · 2,598 sq ft
7003 SW Wisteria Terrace, Palm City, FL 34990 · $1,475,000 · 5 bd · 5 ba · 4,052 sq ft
1100 SW Squire Johns Lane, Palm City, FL 34990 · $1,275,000 · 3 bd · 3 ba · 2,633 sq ft
1608 SW CATTAIL Court, Palm City, FL 34990 · $1,289,999 · 3 bd · 3 ba · 2,627 sq ft

Recently Sold Nearby

841 SW Catalina Street, Palm City, FL 34990 · Sold $1,280,000 · 4 bd · 3 ba · 3,166 sq ft
5781 SW Star Apple Street, Palm City, FL 34990 · Sold $1,175,000 · 3 bd · 4 ba · 3,176 sq ft
3401 SW Holly Lane, Palm City, FL 34990 · Sold $1,150,000 · 7 bd · 4 ba · 4,759 sq ft
2044 SW English Garden Drive, Palm City, FL 34990 · Sold $1,075,000 · 4 bd · 5 ba · 3,523 sq ft

Explore Nearby

Nearby Cities

More Palm City Neighborhoods

Nearby ZIP Codes

The 4 bedroom home at 5080 SW 69th Street, Palm City, FL 34990 is comparable and listed for sale at $1,325,000. Another comparable home, 841 SW Catalina Street, Palm City, FL 34990, sold for $1,280,000 in August 2026. Other Palm City neighborhoods include Piper's Landing and Harbour Ridge Yacht & Country Club. Nearby ZIP codes include 34994 and 34996. This property also neighbors Stuart, Jensen Beach, and Port St. Lucie. Compare it with the Palm City housing market report.