What did 12585 S 89th Street sell for?

12585 S 89th Street sold for $695,000 on May 6, 2026, about 100% of its last asking price of $695,000 and about $358 per square foot. Recent sales like this one are what buyers and sellers nearby price against.

What are the property taxes on 12585 S 89th Street?

The listing reported annual property taxes of $2,310 for 2025. Taxes are reassessed at the sale price after a purchase, so the new owner's bill will differ from that figure.

When was 12585 S 89th Street built?

12585 S 89th Street was built in 2005 and the listing describes its condition as resale. Age matters for insurance and financing in Florida: ask about the roof, the electrical panel and, for a condo built before the current code, the building's structural reserve study.

How long was 12585 S 89th Street on the market?

12585 S 89th Street was on the market for 10 days before it sold.

Which schools serve 12585 S 89th Street?

The MLS lists Treasure Coast (elementary), Sebastian River (middle), Sebastian River (high). School assignments are set by the district and can change; verify them with the school board before you rely on them.

Is 12585 S 89th Street still for sale?

No. 12585 S 89th Street sold on May 6, 2026. BreakThru Realty can show you similar homes for sale nearby, or tell you what a home like yours would sell for today; call or text and a licensed agent will follow up.

12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere, FL 32948

Sold $695,000 · May 6, 2026

Last asking price $695,000 · 100% of asking · 10 days on market

3 beds
3 baths
1,944 sq ft
Single Family Residence
Built 2005
Lot 217,800 sq ft
Indian River County
MLS# B26010878
Fellsmere Farms Co S/D Of Unsurveyed Twp 31 Rng 37

1_smg04065.1 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

5_smg04076 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

58_dji_20260402071257_0134_d.1 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

33_smg04230 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

39_smg04260.1 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

42_smg04270 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

55_dji_20260402071150_0114_d at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

2_smg04060 at 12585 S 89th Street, Fellsmere

About this home

Charming farmhouse retreat offering the perfect blend of country living and convenience. This fully fenced 5 ACRE property w/ southern exposure features a picturesque lake and a babbling creek, along with a pole barn, livestock barn with hen house/horse stalls, and adtl shed for storage. Enjoy a bright open-concept layout with a first-floor primary suite, screened back porch with spa overlooking lake. Circular driveway provides easy access, no HOA's add flexibility. A true farmer's dream—ideal for growing your own fruits and vegetables—with an easy commute to nearby amenities. Gas on property.

Features

High Ceilings
Kitchen Island
Pull Down Stairs
Garden

Schools

Elementary: Treasure Coast
Middle: Sebastian River
High: Sebastian River

Presented by

BreakThru Realty · (786) 914-1017

Courtesy of

Billero & Billero - Beach Offc · Billero@aol.com · Listing agent: Eugene L Billero II

All listings featuring the BMLS logo are provided by BeachesMLS, Inc. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by BeachesMLS. Listings held by brokerage firms other than BreakThru Realty carry the name of the listing broker.

What is your home worth?

12585 S 89th Street sold on May 6, 2026. If you own nearby, get a free home valuation or see homes for sale in Fellsmere. Call or text BreakThru Realty at (786) 914-1017 or email sales@breakthrurealty.com.

Questions About 12585 S 89th Street

What did 12585 S 89th Street sell for?: 12585 S 89th Street sold for $695,000 on May 6, 2026, about 100% of its last asking price of $695,000 and about $358 per square foot. Recent sales like this one are what buyers and sellers nearby price against.
What are the property taxes on 12585 S 89th Street?: The listing reported annual property taxes of $2,310 for 2025. Taxes are reassessed at the sale price after a purchase, so the new owner's bill will differ from that figure.
When was 12585 S 89th Street built?: 12585 S 89th Street was built in 2005 and the listing describes its condition as resale. Age matters for insurance and financing in Florida: ask about the roof, the electrical panel and, for a condo built before the current code, the building's structural reserve study.
How long was 12585 S 89th Street on the market?: 12585 S 89th Street was on the market for 10 days before it sold.
Which schools serve 12585 S 89th Street?: The MLS lists Treasure Coast (elementary), Sebastian River (middle), Sebastian River (high). School assignments are set by the district and can change; verify them with the school board before you rely on them.
Is 12585 S 89th Street still for sale?: No. 12585 S 89th Street sold on May 6, 2026. BreakThru Realty can show you similar homes for sale nearby, or tell you what a home like yours would sell for today; call or text and a licensed agent will follow up.

Explore

Explore Nearby

Nearby Cities

Nearby ZIP Codes

Nearby ZIP codes include 32958 and 32963. This property also neighbors Sebastian, Indian River Shores, and Vero Beach. Compare it with the Fellsmere housing market report.