How much do homes at Diamond Shores cost?

Homes at Diamond Shores are listed from $3,750,000 right now, a median $962 per square foot. Over the last twelve months homes closed at a median $3,750,000. Size, position, view and finish drive the spread; these figures refresh daily from the MLS.

What are the association fees at Diamond Shores?

The median association fee on current and recent listings at Diamond Shores is $505 a month. Fees vary by home size and what the association covers, and older communities may add special assessments for inspections and repairs, so we confirm the fee, the budget and any assessment for the specific home.

Can I rent out a home at Diamond Shores?

The Diamond Shores association decides: most South Florida associations set a minimum lease term, limit how many times a year a home may be leased and require tenant approval, and some require an owner to hold the home for a period first. 2 homes are listed for rent in the community right now, which shows leasing is possible; we read the current rules before you buy.

Are pets allowed at Diamond Shores?

Listings at Diamond Shores describe the pet policy as "Yes, Number Limit, Size Limit". Weight, breed and number limits are set by the association and can change, so we confirm the current rule for your pet before you offer or apply.

How do I see a home at Diamond Shores?

Request a showing from any listing on this page, or ask a BreakThru agent to arrange a private tour of the homes for sale or for rent at Diamond Shores. We also compare the community with similar Fort Pierce homes so you can see the choice side by side.

Diamond Shores Homes for Sale & Rent in Fort Pierce

Diamond Shores homes in Fort Pierce, FL: 1 for sale from $3,750,000, rentals, recent sales, price per square foot and association fees from live MLS data, updated daily.

Diamond Shores at a Glance

Address	4316 DIAMOND SHORES WAY / 4356 DIAMOND SHORES WAY
Year built	2023 (new construction)
Units for sale	1
Asking prices	$3,750,000
Median asking price per sq ft	$962/sq ft
Median association fee	$505/mo
Units for rent	2
Median asking rent	$15,000/mo
Sold in the last 12 months	1
Median sold price	$3,750,000
Sale price as % of list	98.7%
Leased in the last 12 months	0
Median leased rent	n/a
Median leased rent per sq ft	n/a
Average days to lease	n/a
Leased rent as % of asking	n/a
Water frontage	Ocean Front, Ocean Access
Pet policy (per listings)	Yes, Number Limit, Size Limit

Source: BeachesMLS, every listing at the building's address; figures refresh daily. Not an appraisal.

About Diamond Shores

Diamond Shores is an enclave of oceanfront single family homes on Diamond Shores Way on Hutchinson Island, between the Atlantic Ocean and the Intracoastal Waterway, with a Fort Pierce address. Its addresses are 4316 Diamond Shores Way and 4356 Diamond Shores Way, completed in 2023 according to the MLS. Listings describe its water frontage as ocean front, ocean access. This page gathers every home the MLS shows at the community's addresses: the ones for sale, the rentals and the closings of the last twelve months.

Diamond Shores Homes for Sale

1 home is for sale at Diamond Shores right now at $3,750,000, at a median $962 per square foot, with 4 bedrooms. The median association fee on these listings is $505 a month; what it covers differs by building, so confirm it for the home.

Recent Sales and Rentals at Diamond Shores

1 home closed in the last twelve months at a median $3,750,000 ($959 per square foot), at 98.7% of the asking price after 227 days on market. 2 homes are for rent at a median $15,000 a month; the association sets the minimum lease term and the approval process.

Before You Buy at Diamond Shores

A home at Diamond Shores comes with an association whose documents matter as much as the house: we read its budget, any special assessment and the rules on leasing, pets and exterior changes, and we check the survey, the roof and the windows, the flood zone and the insurance, and on newer construction the builder's warranty, before you make an offer.

Homes for Sale at Diamond Shores

$3,750,000
4316 Diamond Shores Way, Fort Pierce FL 34949
4 bd · 6 ba · 3,897 sq ft · Single Family Residence

Homes for Rent at Diamond Shores

Recently Sold at Diamond Shores

Sold $3,750,000
Closed Jun 8, 2026 · 4356 Diamond Shores Way, Hutchinson Island FL 34949
4 bd · 6 ba · 3,911 sq ft · $959/sq ft · 227 days on market · 98.7% of list price

Own a Home at Diamond Shores?

A buyer working with BreakThru Realty may already be looking for a residence like yours. BreakThru Realty works with hundreds of prequalified buyers searching for properties. Request a review of recent sales at Diamond Shores, the competing listings in the building and your selling options, with no buyer named and nothing shared until you decide.

A value range built from comparable Diamond Shores sales, with the reasoning
Whether a buyer already working with BreakThru Realty is looking for a property like yours
The plan that reaches the rest of the market if no buyer on file fits
An estimate of your selling costs and what you would keep after closing

Explore My Diamond Shores Selling Options · Get My Fort Pierce Home Value

Leased at Diamond Shores in the Last 12 Months

What homes at the community actually rented for: each closed lease with the rent it closed at, the days it took and how it compared with the asking rent. Rental portals show asking rents; these are achieved rents from BeachesMLS.

No lease recorded at the community in the last twelve months.

Diamond Shores: Frequently Asked Questions

How much do homes at Diamond Shores cost?: Homes at Diamond Shores are listed from $3,750,000 right now, a median $962 per square foot. Over the last twelve months homes closed at a median $3,750,000. Size, position, view and finish drive the spread; these figures refresh daily from the MLS.
What are the association fees at Diamond Shores?: The median association fee on current and recent listings at Diamond Shores is $505 a month. Fees vary by home size and what the association covers, and older communities may add special assessments for inspections and repairs, so we confirm the fee, the budget and any assessment for the specific home.
Can I rent out a home at Diamond Shores?: The Diamond Shores association decides: most South Florida associations set a minimum lease term, limit how many times a year a home may be leased and require tenant approval, and some require an owner to hold the home for a period first. 2 homes are listed for rent in the community right now, which shows leasing is possible; we read the current rules before you buy.
Are pets allowed at Diamond Shores?: Listings at Diamond Shores describe the pet policy as "Yes, Number Limit, Size Limit". Weight, breed and number limits are set by the association and can change, so we confirm the current rule for your pet before you offer or apply.
How do I see a home at Diamond Shores?: Request a showing from any listing on this page, or ask a BreakThru agent to arrange a private tour of the homes for sale or for rent at Diamond Shores. We also compare the community with similar Fort Pierce homes so you can see the choice side by side.
To request a tour, call (786) 914-1017 or email sales@breakthrurealty.com.