How much is 91865 Overseas Highway?

91865 Overseas Highway is listed at $5,999,000, about $591 per square foot of building. Ask for the rent roll, the existing leases and the operating statements: for an income property those, more than the asking price, show what the building is worth.

What is 91865 Overseas Highway zoned?

The listing reports zoning of SC - MULTI-USE. Permitted uses, parking and signage are set by the city or county zoning code, so confirm your intended use with the local zoning office before you close.

How big is 91865 Overseas Highway?

The listing reports 10,150 square feet of building.

What are the property taxes on 91865 Overseas Highway?

The listing reports annual property taxes of $55,119. Florida reassesses a non-homestead property after it sells, so budget for the new owner's bill rather than the current one.

How do I tour 91865 Overseas Highway?

Request a tour from this page or call BreakThru Realty. A licensed agent will arrange access with the listing broker and ask for what the listing leaves out, such as the rent roll, the leases and the operating statements.

91865 Overseas Highway, FL 33070

$5,999,000 · $591 per sq ft · Retail for sale

Property type: Retail
Asking price: $5,999,000
Price per sq ft: $591
Building size: 10,150 sq ft
Lot size: 21,344 sq ft
Zoning: SC - MULTI-USE
Stories: 2
Buildings: 5
Parking spaces: 30
Parcel ID: 00555610000000
MLS#: A12024229

About this property

Exceptional mixed-use investment opportunity in the heart of Tavernier at 91865 Overseas Highway. This fully renovated income-producing property features a strong tenant mix consisting of 10 residential apartments and 5 established commercial tenants, including a popular pizzeria, boutique doctor's office, hair and nail salon, coffee shop, and additional long-term businesses serving the Upper Keys community. The property has undergone extensive interior and exterior renovations with quality craftsmanship and attention to detail throughout, including high-impact windows and doors, updated plumbing and electrical systems, 2023 Metal/Shingle Roofs, new A/C units, paver walkways, exterior lighting, fresh stucco and paint, tile flooring throughout, zebra shades, and fully furnished all inclusive residential units. Positioned along the highly trafficked Overseas Highway corridor, this landmark property in the south end of Key Largo offers stable cash flow, strong rental demand, and substantial annual revenue with market-rate leases already in place. Under the current Profit & Loss Statement, the property is producing approximately a 7% return based on the asking price. Seller financing available with up to $3,000,000 owner financing offered at 4% interest-only payments for up to 3 years. A rare turnkey commercial asset in one of the Florida Keys' most desirable and supply-constrained markets.

Building Features and Utilities

Block
CBS

Operating Statement

Property taxes	$55,119/yr

Income and expenses as the seller entered them in the MLS, not verified. A buyer's lender underwrites from the actual statements and the property tax and insurance a new owner will pay.

About the Business at 91865 Overseas Highway

Included: Building, Furniture, Land, Leases

Presented by

BreakThru Realty · (786) 914-1017

Courtesy of

Cornell Commercial Real Estate · Centurykey@aol.com · Listing agent: Clifford Fitz-Henry Cornell

All listings featuring the BMLS logo are provided by BeachesMLS, Inc. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by BeachesMLS. Listings held by brokerage firms other than BreakThru Realty carry the name of the listing broker.

Request a tour or more information

Call or text BreakThru Realty at (786) 914-1017 or email sales@breakthrurealty.com to tour 91865 Overseas Highway or to ask for what the listing leaves out: the rent roll, the leases and the operating statements.

Questions About 91865 Overseas Highway

How much is 91865 Overseas Highway?: 91865 Overseas Highway is listed at $5,999,000, about $591 per square foot of building. Ask for the rent roll, the existing leases and the operating statements: for an income property those, more than the asking price, show what the building is worth.
What is 91865 Overseas Highway zoned?: The listing reports zoning of SC - MULTI-USE. Permitted uses, parking and signage are set by the city or county zoning code, so confirm your intended use with the local zoning office before you close.
How big is 91865 Overseas Highway?: The listing reports 10,150 square feet of building.
What are the property taxes on 91865 Overseas Highway?: The listing reports annual property taxes of $55,119. Florida reassesses a non-homestead property after it sells, so budget for the new owner's bill rather than the current one.
How do I tour 91865 Overseas Highway?: Request a tour from this page or call BreakThru Realty. A licensed agent will arrange access with the listing broker and ask for what the listing leaves out, such as the rent roll, the leases and the operating statements.